What constitutes a 'religion'?
RELIGION: (Noun)
1. a set of beliefs concerning the cause, nature, and purpose of the universe, especially when considered as the creation of superhuman agency or agencies, usually involving devotional and ritual observances, and often containing a moral code governing the conduct of human affairs.
2. a specific, fundamental set of beliefs and practices generally agreed upon by a number of persons or sects
3. something one believes in and follows devotedly; a point or matter of ethics or conscience
The above definitions, taken from Dictionary.com, focus attention on the essence of what constitutes this universal human phenomena called 'religion'. One might think that the pantheon of religions would contain a relatively static number of belief systems, but as was recently demonstrated in Britain with the acceptance of Druidism, 'new' religions are continuously added to the list. In other parts of the world, partisans promoting cannabis, 'the Force' (a la “Star Wars) and Elvis have tried to claim membership among the faiths recognized by various governments as legitimate religions.
Yet there is one group that seems to meet the above definition yet bristles at the idea that they constitute a religion: atheists.
Perhaps it is because atheists see themselves as opposing those who profess to be religious. They root their faith, not in the nether world of supernatural beings, but instead choose to put their trust in science to explain creation. To them, the label of 'religion' implies acceptance of superstition in lieu of cold, hard scientific facts. Yet looking at their belief system objectively, atheism does indeed seem to appear to fulfill the definition of a religion.
Atheists hold to a set of beliefs concerning the 'cause, nature, and purpose of the universe'. The cause being the 'Big Bang', its nature being explainable by the application of the scientific method and the universe exists without any ultimate purpose – as much an answer based upon their initial assertion of the denial of a supernatural realm as traditional creedal communities have answered this initial question in the affirmative. One need only peruse the comment threads that follow any 'religious' article on the Internet to confirm that atheists strongly and devotedly promote their conviction that God (or 'Sky-Faerie') does not exist. Their devotion to their cause matches the passion and resolve of any committed partisan of religion. In a strange manner, the very fact that so many atheists regularly troll the religion sections of newspapers and websites is evidence that, (perhaps unconsciously) they think of themselves as a religion. Were this not the case, would they not be spending their time involved in conversations on websites dedicated to science rather than religious sites?
Despite claims to the contrary, atheism's devotees act in a religious manner in promoting their creed. “If it walks like a duck, quacks like a duck and looks like a duck....” Atheists should accept the fact that they are an ascendant religion in the 21st century. They might have more success in their attempts to proselytize if they admit that, as a religion, they offer an answer to the eternal questions of life.
Reflections from the pastoral ministry of an Evangelical Catholic Priest.
03 October, 2010
If they walk like a duck, and quack like a duck....
Labels:
atheism,
atheists,
definition of religion,
religion
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
About Fr. Tim
- Fr. Tim Moyle
- A Roman Catholic Evangelical Priest of the Diocese of Pembroke, Canada. Shown in my profile photo with my canine companion, Mateo.
Favorite Links
- American Papist Blog
- American Spectator
- Archbishop Tim Dolan's (NY) Blog
- Big Blue Wave
- Canadian Broadcasting Corporation (CBC News Site)
- Catholic Dialogue Blog
- Catholic Education Resource Center
- Catholic Exchange
- Catholic Heritage Website (Ireland)
- Catholic Insight
- Catholic News Agency
- Catholic Online
- Catholic Sensibility
- Catholic, and Loving It
- CTV News Site
- Ethics and Public Policy Center
- First Things
- Fr. Raymond De Souza - National Post Columnist
- Fr. Raymond deSouza personal blog
- Freethroughthought blog (excellent site)
- Friar Rick's Webblog
- Get Religion.org
- Global TV News Site
- Holy Post - National Post Religious Blog
- Inside Catholic Blog
- LifeSiteNews
- New Advent
- Pave the Way Foundation
- Priests for Life Canada Website
- ProLife Blog
- Roman Catholic Diocese of Pembroke
- Rosary for the Bishops
- Salt & Light TV - Canadian Catholic Television Website
- Sandro Magister
- Sane Conservatism
- SoCon (social conservative)
- Sylvia's Website: Canadian Clergy Sex Abuse Cases
- The Catholic Register
- The Hermeneutic of Continuity
- The National Post: Canada's National Daily
- The New Jesuit Review
- The New York Times Website
- Vox Nova
- What Does Prayer Really Say - Priest bolg
- Whispers in the Loggia
Blog Archive
-
▼
2010
(997)
-
▼
October
(94)
- We Salute Our Heroes
- Khadr jury asks for replay of defence witness test...
- Druids Committed Human Sacrifice, Cannibalism?
- "Diamonds scattered on black velvet" A Canadian as...
- Review of the Jon Stewart / Stephen Colbert Rally ...
- The tendency to vote liberal might be in your gene...
- One winning ticket for $50M Lotto Max draw sold in...
- Charles Lewis: The religious must be better prepar...
- Would you take a 'one way' trip to Mars?
- Pope: The Church Doesn't Fear Science | Daily News...
- Debate: Do Catholics have anything to gain from di...
- Let Family Members of Suicides Kill Themselves Too...
- Seven Key Catholic Social Principles
- 'DING DONG': Answering the door is a test of faith...
- Nuit Blanche: Spectacular, breath-taking and Canad...
- Addendum: Locke & Natural Law « The American Catho...
- Pope Announces 2012 Synod on the 'New Evangelizati...
- Canadian dollar rises, greenback resumes fall - CT...
- Liberals defend sanctity of free speech for libera...
- 'Imagination in straitjacket'
- How Far Should Forgiveness Go? | Christianity Toda...
- 'I am the very model of a modern US President' - h...
- Conrad Black: Brother AndrĂ©’s Catholic Church help...
- Catholic Political Thought & John Locke: Part II «...
- B.C. bishop in hospital after attack at rectory - ...
- First response to Commonweal article!
- A remarkable and thought-provoking assessment of t...
- Teachers to be given flexibility on missed deadlin...
- Spiritual Call to arms: Monday OCTOBER 25, 2010 - ...
- A note from a friend of this blog!!
- Catholic Political Thought & John Locke: Part I « ...
- President Obama Edits the Declaration of Independe...
- Heavyweight Philosophers Clash at Abortion Confere...
- What is a Cardinal and What is the Purpose of the ...
- Papal humor: JPII had a funny side too!
- Should Canada have a guaranteed annual income? - T...
- What a wonderful topic for an agenda: How 'Scornfu...
- Likely new Cardinals to be named tomorrow... inclu...
- ARCHBISHOP CHAPUT: The First Freedom: religious li...
- Homer Simpson a Catholic, Vatican says | Holy Post...
- The making of a saint - The Globe and Mail
- Golfers 'heaven' or perhaps a watery grave for a g...
- ZENIT - Family Life in Flux
- Conrad Black: Court moderate Muslims, but treat th...
- Another Protestant Discovers the Problems of Sola ...
- Planned Parenthood: American tax dollars at work!
- The Bible and Cognitive Dissonance
- Scientists dissect the workings of greed - CTV New...
- Brother AndrĂ©’s life reflects beauty of holy humil...
- Pro-Life Victory: KS Supreme Court Allows Planned ...
- Great quotation from a Canadian philosopher
- Is the Sacrament of Confession Biblical?
- Teresa of Avila - a Doctor for our times
- They who confront false gods
- The Quiet Faith Behind Colbert's Right-Wing Funnym...
- Euthanasia workshops test legal boundaries
- Pro-Life ad that the Irish government won't allow ...
- Andy Richter and Conan O'Brien to reunite on TBS t...
- First ‘atheistic civilisation’ is heading for cata...
- Pope creates new office to fight 'eclipse of God' ...
- Birth analogy: Appropriate? What do you think?
- Flaherty seen to stay on course on economy
- The Wild West of the blogosphere can revitalise th...
- Drug money saved banks in global crisis, claims UN...
- Pope sketches 'positive secularism' for Middle Eas...
- Pope: "Terrorism presented in the name of God must...
- Israeli Christians: Uncomfortable Minority, Mutual...
- The BEST Thanksgiving routine in the history of te...
- Amarnath Amarasingam: Are American College Profess...
- What keeps the Pro-Life crowd going?
- "Life is a 'privilege', not a right". YIKES!!!
- Freedom Through Truth: What is the Fruit of Disobe...
- No right to lawyer during questioning, SCC rules -...
- Do graphic anti-abortion posters cross a moral lin...
- Sharing the space
- Vatican’s ‘Special Middle East Assembly’ set to be...
- Canadian Centre for Bio-Ethical Reform
- Couple urged surrogate mother to abort fetus becau...
- Fewer Children, Later Marriage, More Divorce in Ca...
- The Reasoned Loyalty of Catholicism | First Things...
- Marriage: Is it still important? - Point of View
- Shock! Smothering A Disabled Child An Act of Love?...
- Hegel on Wall Street - NYTimes.com
- God Weeps: Cardinal Martino on the Growing Threat ...
- Whispers in the Loggia: Pushkin's Pope
- Academic Freedom? Not for Catholics evidently!
- Secular worship
- The Infallibility of the Pope and the Magisterium ...
- Freedom Through Truth: Father Mark Gruber - The Pl...
- What is the link between economics and morality? |...
- If they walk like a duck, and quack like a duck......
- Believe it or not... this is actually a government...
- What I Ask of Science | Archdiocese of Washington
- The Enduring Power of John Paul II’s Example
-
▼
October
(94)
No, Tim. You're engaging in binary thinking, here, and that is leading you into a common error -- that there are only two ways of looking at a thing, and both involve something you call "belief."
ReplyDeleteAtheists have NO BELIEF. It is not that they believe there are no gods; it is that they do not believe there are any gods. Can you not tell the difference?
Sorry Lady Janus. I truthfully do not see the difference. To my way of thinking, it is an 'A=B/B=A' type of argument.
ReplyDeleteOne the one hand:
'they believe that there are no Gods'
On the other hand
'they do not believe that there are any Gods'
How are they different?
Thanks.
Your binary bud,
Fr. Tim
The difference is in the focus of the thought, and when you are dealing with theism and atheism, the focus is belief, not existence.
ReplyDeleteA theist believes in god(s).
An atheist does not believe in god(s).
An antitheist believes there are no gods.
It's not atheists who oppose religion in others -- that belongs to the antitheists. And if you look at the roots of the different words, you will note that "anti" means "against," but "a" means simply, "without."
How can one without religion have a religion?
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteLady Janus: Thank you. In response may I note that I had not considered that there was a differentiation between atheists and anti-theists. I assumed that they represent differences in degree than in species or kind.
ReplyDeleteMay I ask you: Can being without religion BE a religion? I think that is the question at hand.
What a subject possesses is a belief. One group believes that there is a God(s)/supernatural force. Another group holds to a different belief that such a being/force does not or could not exist.
I appreciate that atheists do not completely encompass the fullness of the definition of a religion. But at the same time, I hold that they do meet the minimum standard.
Did you have a chance to see the article in the Ottawa Citizen? Although our arguments are only tangentially related, I take as a measure of validation that there are others in the culture who are thinking along the same lines.
Fr. Tim
P.S. The arrival of autumn has continued the wave of deaths in our parish. It's interesting how it is that we are truly part of the cycles of life that waxes and wanes around us. Blessedly, these deaths have all been of individuals who have quietly died in their very old age. The celebrations of their funerals carried for all a sense of joy and appreciation for the gifts the deceased had been for them for so many years. It's affirming and humbling to share in these events in so many people's lives.
To be a priest is truly a 'blessed' vocation.
Fr. Tim