What a remarkable coincidence! The day after I post a story setting out the argument that atheism could be considered a religion, here's a another post from the Ottawa Citizen stating that 'consumerism' has obtained the status of a 'religion' among today's citizens.
I am sincerely trying to understand the arguments made here by Lady Janus and on the Holy Post by 'Rationalist1'. Their point is nuanced and I am having trouble accepting it, but I keep on reading and searching for material such as the Citizen story to help me clarify and refine my logic so that I can decide for myself whether my initial assertion about 'atheism' as a community of belief - for believing that something exists or does not exist seems essentially to me to be the same act.
It is a statement of belief. It is a statement about the essential nature of creation. It is a statement about all that is important regarding the human condition. It bears even to the issue of what is life itself. All of these things are constitutive elements of all world religions.
 |
| Hummm..... |
Anyone who can help me see this from another perspective so that I can measure justly, correctly and properly this proposition of mine would be very much welcomed here. Feel free either to comment below this post or to email me directly at tim.moyle@stannesparish.ca
Thanks.
Fr. Tim
Secular worship
Blog Archive
-
▼
2010
(997)
-
▼
October
(94)
- We Salute Our Heroes
- Khadr jury asks for replay of defence witness test...
- Druids Committed Human Sacrifice, Cannibalism?
- "Diamonds scattered on black velvet" A Canadian as...
- Review of the Jon Stewart / Stephen Colbert Rally ...
- The tendency to vote liberal might be in your gene...
- One winning ticket for $50M Lotto Max draw sold in...
- Charles Lewis: The religious must be better prepar...
- Would you take a 'one way' trip to Mars?
- Pope: The Church Doesn't Fear Science | Daily News...
- Debate: Do Catholics have anything to gain from di...
- Let Family Members of Suicides Kill Themselves Too...
- Seven Key Catholic Social Principles
- 'DING DONG': Answering the door is a test of faith...
- Nuit Blanche: Spectacular, breath-taking and Canad...
- Addendum: Locke & Natural Law « The American Catho...
- Pope Announces 2012 Synod on the 'New Evangelizati...
- Canadian dollar rises, greenback resumes fall - CT...
- Liberals defend sanctity of free speech for libera...
- 'Imagination in straitjacket'
- How Far Should Forgiveness Go? | Christianity Toda...
- 'I am the very model of a modern US President' - h...
- Conrad Black: Brother AndrĂ©’s Catholic Church help...
- Catholic Political Thought & John Locke: Part II «...
- B.C. bishop in hospital after attack at rectory - ...
- First response to Commonweal article!
- A remarkable and thought-provoking assessment of t...
- Teachers to be given flexibility on missed deadlin...
- Spiritual Call to arms: Monday OCTOBER 25, 2010 - ...
- A note from a friend of this blog!!
- Catholic Political Thought & John Locke: Part I « ...
- President Obama Edits the Declaration of Independe...
- Heavyweight Philosophers Clash at Abortion Confere...
- What is a Cardinal and What is the Purpose of the ...
- Papal humor: JPII had a funny side too!
- Should Canada have a guaranteed annual income? - T...
- What a wonderful topic for an agenda: How 'Scornfu...
- Likely new Cardinals to be named tomorrow... inclu...
- ARCHBISHOP CHAPUT: The First Freedom: religious li...
- Homer Simpson a Catholic, Vatican says | Holy Post...
- The making of a saint - The Globe and Mail
- Golfers 'heaven' or perhaps a watery grave for a g...
- ZENIT - Family Life in Flux
- Conrad Black: Court moderate Muslims, but treat th...
- Another Protestant Discovers the Problems of Sola ...
- Planned Parenthood: American tax dollars at work!
- The Bible and Cognitive Dissonance
- Scientists dissect the workings of greed - CTV New...
- Brother AndrĂ©’s life reflects beauty of holy humil...
- Pro-Life Victory: KS Supreme Court Allows Planned ...
- Great quotation from a Canadian philosopher
- Is the Sacrament of Confession Biblical?
- Teresa of Avila - a Doctor for our times
- They who confront false gods
- The Quiet Faith Behind Colbert's Right-Wing Funnym...
- Euthanasia workshops test legal boundaries
- Pro-Life ad that the Irish government won't allow ...
- Andy Richter and Conan O'Brien to reunite on TBS t...
- First ‘atheistic civilisation’ is heading for cata...
- Pope creates new office to fight 'eclipse of God' ...
- Birth analogy: Appropriate? What do you think?
- Flaherty seen to stay on course on economy
- The Wild West of the blogosphere can revitalise th...
- Drug money saved banks in global crisis, claims UN...
- Pope sketches 'positive secularism' for Middle Eas...
- Pope: "Terrorism presented in the name of God must...
- Israeli Christians: Uncomfortable Minority, Mutual...
- The BEST Thanksgiving routine in the history of te...
- Amarnath Amarasingam: Are American College Profess...
- What keeps the Pro-Life crowd going?
- "Life is a 'privilege', not a right". YIKES!!!
- Freedom Through Truth: What is the Fruit of Disobe...
- No right to lawyer during questioning, SCC rules -...
- Do graphic anti-abortion posters cross a moral lin...
- Sharing the space
- Vatican’s ‘Special Middle East Assembly’ set to be...
- Canadian Centre for Bio-Ethical Reform
- Couple urged surrogate mother to abort fetus becau...
- Fewer Children, Later Marriage, More Divorce in Ca...
- The Reasoned Loyalty of Catholicism | First Things...
- Marriage: Is it still important? - Point of View
- Shock! Smothering A Disabled Child An Act of Love?...
- Hegel on Wall Street - NYTimes.com
- God Weeps: Cardinal Martino on the Growing Threat ...
- Whispers in the Loggia: Pushkin's Pope
- Academic Freedom? Not for Catholics evidently!
- Secular worship
- The Infallibility of the Pope and the Magisterium ...
- Freedom Through Truth: Father Mark Gruber - The Pl...
- What is the link between economics and morality? |...
- If they walk like a duck, and quack like a duck......
- Believe it or not... this is actually a government...
- What I Ask of Science | Archdiocese of Washington
- The Enduring Power of John Paul II’s Example
Separate from the question of is atheism a religion, the article on consumerism in modern society leaves me wondering why this is classified as religion.
ReplyDeleteFirst only if the word religion is degraded so much that it ceases to have any meaning (i.e. baseball is my religion, shopping is my religion, etc.) If the word science were subject to such abuse, I would be complaining.
Secondly, and this perhaps needs no comment, consumerism is not limited to those without beliefs, it is rampant in all of society.