Reflections from the pastoral ministry of an Evangelical Catholic Priest.
17 December, 2010
An opinion on the relationships between atheists and theists from the National Post
Charlie Lewis of the Holy Post has offered another opinion piece on the relationship between atheists and believers. You can read it here. Among the numerous comments that have been generated, Charlie responds to one poster in a manner that succinctly brings a light to the reason why we believers demand that our voices be heard in the public square. I share it in the hopes that it might generate a discussion here on his assessment.
Labels:
atheism,
Charles Lewis,
Holy Post,
National Post,
theists
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
About Fr. Tim
- Fr. Tim Moyle
- A Roman Catholic Evangelical Priest of the Diocese of Pembroke, Canada. Shown in my profile photo with my canine companion, Mateo.
Favorite Links
- American Papist Blog
- American Spectator
- Archbishop Tim Dolan's (NY) Blog
- Big Blue Wave
- Canadian Broadcasting Corporation (CBC News Site)
- Catholic Dialogue Blog
- Catholic Education Resource Center
- Catholic Exchange
- Catholic Heritage Website (Ireland)
- Catholic Insight
- Catholic News Agency
- Catholic Online
- Catholic Sensibility
- Catholic, and Loving It
- CTV News Site
- Ethics and Public Policy Center
- First Things
- Fr. Raymond De Souza - National Post Columnist
- Fr. Raymond deSouza personal blog
- Freethroughthought blog (excellent site)
- Friar Rick's Webblog
- Get Religion.org
- Global TV News Site
- Holy Post - National Post Religious Blog
- Inside Catholic Blog
- LifeSiteNews
- New Advent
- Pave the Way Foundation
- Priests for Life Canada Website
- ProLife Blog
- Roman Catholic Diocese of Pembroke
- Rosary for the Bishops
- Salt & Light TV - Canadian Catholic Television Website
- Sandro Magister
- Sane Conservatism
- SoCon (social conservative)
- Sylvia's Website: Canadian Clergy Sex Abuse Cases
- The Catholic Register
- The Hermeneutic of Continuity
- The National Post: Canada's National Daily
- The New Jesuit Review
- The New York Times Website
- Vox Nova
- What Does Prayer Really Say - Priest bolg
- Whispers in the Loggia
Blog Archive
-
▼
2010
(997)
-
▼
December
(72)
- Most under-reported Vatican stories of 2010 | Nati...
- Baghdad: 14 bombs target Christian homes
- Arizona storm: Phoenix-area hit with rain, snow in...
- Freedom Through Truth: Of Christians and Atheists
- A Little New Year's Advice - Megan McArdle - Perso...
- 50th anniversary of John Courtney Murray’s We Hold...
- Christianity: 100 Years of Boom & Bust | December ...
- Top 10 Vatican news stories from 2010
- Fr. Thomas Doyle: the Vatican’s most critical insi...
- Lose the religion or lose the subsidy - The Globe ...
- Pope Benedict XVI Offers Hopeful Christmas Message...
- Merry Christmas to everyone!
- Islamic group threatens Copts living in Canada
- Graphic: Who gives? Canadians’ charitable donation...
- An atheist view of December – CNN Belief Blog - CN...
- Here's the best Santa letter I've ever seen!
- Santa Claus a Canadian, immigration minister reaff...
- Bad diagnosis : Pharyngula
- Being on God’s Side: An Open Letter to the Religio...
- Why Religious People Are Scared of Atheists | | Al...
- The origins of secularism
- Al Qaeda-affiliated website targets Arab Christian...
- WikiLeaks’ master leaker upset at being leaked aga...
- A social network telling of the Christmas story
- Churches halt decline, new research shows - Telegr...
- Heroic, Female and Muslim - NYTimes.com
- Pope Urges Church to Reflect on Abuse - NYTimes.co...
- Your Monday smile
- Lunar Eclipse to Take Place December 21 - ABC News...
- Good will to all men? Not from the grumpy atheists...
- The state of our unions The future of marriage can...
- ‘End hostility, prejudice’ in Europe: Pope | Holy ...
- If cats could talk...
- A secularist responds to Charles Lewis | Holy Post...
- Conrad Black: Catholics persevere, despite the per...
- Another interesting article from John Allen in whi...
- An opinion on the relationships between atheists a...
- Switzerland considers reducing the taboo on incest...
- Archbishop Timothy Dolan Explains Why We Need the ...
- Pope Compares Fundamentalism With Secularism - NYT...
- A Christmas letter from Jesus: An oldie but a good...
- The mystery of Mona Lisa and Amelia Earhart solved...
- Is the Bottom Really Falling Out of Catholic Mass ...
- Too good not to pass along to my fellow travellers...
- Clergy shortage affecting all denominations in Can...
- Time continues misrepresentation on Pope Benedict
- So, Why Is Incest Wrong? The next social 'advancem...
- The future of faith in Canada - The Globe and Mail...
- What to put in your winter survival kit - The Glob...
- Looking for a good book to give as a gift to a Chr...
- B16 Christmas Wish: Concrete Charity... and A Call...
- A little inspiration in the midst of all the seaso...
- Vatican reaction to WikiLeaks claims | World news ...
- Wikileaks poses the threat of information terroris...
- Science video in which tribute is given to the won...
- Canada marching away from religion to secularizati...
- When Nothing Created Everything | First Things
- Here's a video prepared by one of priests (Fr. Réa...
- The Pink Candle and Other Musings
- Grace under fire - McLeans Magazine re-evaluates P...
- Alien star that shouldn't exist is discovered - U....
- The Changing Culture War - NYTimes.com
- An interview with Archbishop Tim Dolan of New York...
- Dear atheists: most of us don’t care what you thin...
- Fetal remains at the centre of trial in North Bay,...
- Freedom Through Truth: I Had a Dream
- Just a heartfelt message to remind us that as we a...
- Eating Our Young | Blogs | NCRegister.com
- NASA announcement will 'impact the search' for lif...
- Pope in 1988 sought to remove abusers faster » Ven...
- If Christmas shopping were actually like this... I...
- Catholics Fire Back in Christmas Billboard Battle ...
-
▼
December
(72)
To answer some of Charlie's points: "I'm just as valuable a citizen as you are."
ReplyDeleteOf course you are. But you're not more valuable. Not for any reason. But especially not for reasons of religious affiliation. Or lack of it.
"The other issue is you're assuming all religions are the same."
And it appears as though you assume all atheists are the same. It also appears that you view all non-Christians as atheists.
"...the concern of many religious people is in the realm of social justices, relieving third world debt, reducing poverty."
You're saying that as if you think non-religious folk do not care about social justice, poverty, and debt. When did such become strictly the purview of religion?
"Give me one concrete example of someone trying to shove anything down your throat."
Political activity, trying to enact laws for the entire country based on one's own religious ideals, when they are not voluntarily shared by everyone else. You, personally, may not do it, but there are your co-religionists who do, and they claim to be speaking for you, too! And they are loud and insistent about that. So if you, personally, do not like being lumped in with all those irritating buttinskies on street corners who iinsist that they do, indeed, speak for you, then hadn't you better take it up with them?
Lady Janus
ReplyDeleteit is wonderful to live in a free country where "political activity" is open to everyone...so if a group is lobbying for something you don't agree with you are just as free to lobby against it so sharing in them is not a requirement...depending on the issue i believe it is passion and conviction and where we lobby or protest or not is always an individual decision.
I hope u have a wonderful Christmas and that 2011 will be a year filled with many blessings and with wishes that come true:))
Mary, you are misunderstanding me. I am not against political activity for anyone. I am against someone else's religious agenda's being applied to me without my consent, courtesy of that politicial activity!
ReplyDeleteI am having an exhausting Yule (great fun, these Yule festivals, but oh! so ennervating!), and plan on hiding from the world for a week after sundown tomorrow. Today. The twenty-first.
You have a wonderful Christmas!
Lady Janus,
ReplyDelete"Political activity, trying to enact laws for the entire country based on one's own religious ideals, when they are not voluntarily shared by everyone else. You, personally, may not do it, but there are your co-religionists who do, and they claim to be speaking for you, too!"
Everyone, regardless of what religion they are, or no religion, or agnostic, or athiest, is entitled to lobby the government through legal ways to try get them enact laws which they wish to have. I suppose if you don't agree with a particular law, you could say it is being forced down your throat, but that is the essence of democracy isn't it? What was that famous saying, a government or leader can please some of the people some of the time, but not all of the people all of the time or something like that? Seasons greetings.